Distinguishing the Differences Between Rape Culture & Rape Fantasy

I had a follower on Twitter who said she would have shared one of my blog articles except “the page features (a) Glamour Mag Cover Woman smiling while her clothes are ripped off.”

Here is the “offending” photo:

AGWDM glamour brazil

For almost a year that picture has been on the right margin of my site (it links to an article, Saiba quais são os 100 melhores blogs de sexo do mundo (Which are the Top 100 Sex Blogs in the World). As No. 17, I think anyone can understand why I display it on the right margin of my post pages with pride. I never thought much about the cover except, “Hey, pretty cheeky. What woman wouldn’t want or fantasize about multiple men wanting a piece of her?” I never thought of it as violent or demeaning to women. The photo is obviously posed and the woman’s clothes aren’t actually being ripped off her body.

I explained what the photo link was on my site was all about and apologized if it was a trigger.

It turned out that it wasn’t a trigger for her but instead, “…more perpetration of rape culture. It’s a trip to see names I know would be opposed when clicking through,” she tweeted.

All I could think of saying in reply was, “I think we need to do a better job of distinguishing rape, rape culture & mutual consensual rough sex (ie rape fantasy).”

So let that start with me.

Rape: As of Jan. 1, 2013, the U.S. Federal Bureau of Investigation considers rape to be: “Penetration, no matter how slight, of the vagina or anus with any body part or object, or oral penetration by a sex organ of another person, without the consent of the victim.” (The full explanation is outlined here.) Keep in mind the key word is “consent”.

Rape Culture: Rape culture gets a little harder to officially define because those who define it, even at the academic research level, don’t uniformly define it. To me, rape culture persists among people (mostly men) who:

a. are angry at women who turn them down for sex and feel entitled to get what they are (supposedly) giving to other men.

b. see women as objects and commodities like actors in pornographic adult films and pictures, especially in themes and scenes when women appear to be forcibly used solely for male pleasure.

c. have a cultural belief that men are entitled to sex whether or not a woman wants it.

d. have a cultural belief that any woman who dresses or acts provocatively is “asking for it.”

e. believe acts like rough sex and BDSM are all about a man’s (usually) entitlement to hit, injure and physically and verbally abuse partners (usually female) than extreme mutual and consensual sensual, physical and psychological sexual play.

I take this stuff seriously. Dead seriously.

AGWDM rough sex featuredNow there are people who really get off on “rape fantasy”, which in actuality is consensual rough sex. This is done with pre-negotiation between both partners with an understanding that safe words are used and/or “no” means “no” no matter how far this kind of sex play goes. There is an understanding of the difference between non-consent and acting non-consensually, and furthermore, respect (if not love) between partners after the rough sex play pans out.

My biggest piece of advice to those who are into rough sex/rape fantasy: choose your partner(s) wisely, preferably someone you trust and know well.

If you’ve paid attention, the words “consent” and “consensual” have come up 10 times before this paragraph. The only people who need to be concerned about consent are you and your partner. It’s nobody else’s business and it’s no uninvolved person’s place to say what is and isn’t acceptable for you and your partner to practice and enjoy, even people who say that they’re sex-positive advocates.

As for the Glamour Brasil photo link on my site, I’m not taking it down. If complied with the few individuals who have complained about photos or things I have written on my site, I wouldn’t be true to myself. In all, that might be a dozen people out of over a million page views on my site. I am by no means insensitive to those have negative triggers to some sexual acts. But to act upon someone who assumes how others may react negatively to content on my blog would be just catering to someone who is just hypersensitive and might need a little education in what sex-positivity is all about.

If you feel you’ve been raped or abused, call your local police department or rape or abuse hotlines. It may be an embarrassing, humiliating or even financially devastating thing to go through, but it’s the first step in recovery, healing and taking agency of your life and sexuality.

Shop the latest Lingerie Special Offers at Lovehoney.com
About Bobbie Morgan (1247 Articles)
Bobbie Morgan is the beditor-in-chief of A Good Woman's Dirty Mind. When she's not blogging or having the best sex ever, she's putting out writing and social media services for adult businesses. Use the contact link to reach her by email.

4 Comments on Distinguishing the Differences Between Rape Culture & Rape Fantasy

  1. Fantastic post, Bobbie. Oh, how I wish we could get back to the real crimes & abuse and stay out of the bedrooms of mutually consenting lovers.

    Annie B.

  2. Great article and I definitely agree with your points. Does it ever seem to you that people jump to a place where they can complain they are offended and some people jump to conclusions that make a person a victim – even when its not accurate at all?

  3. The image doesn’t offend me. At first glance I can understand how it could appear to be ‘perpetuating a culture of rape – but at the same time, the woman has the hugest grin on her face. Not the face of someone who is being raped or having their clothes removed against their will (believe me on this one).

    When looking at the photo I think: what if the woman is simply enjoying the realisation of her fantasy – not even rape fantasy but to have sex with multiple men on a single occasion? And if that’s wrong, we stray into the areas of slut shaming.

    It’s an image, it’s provocative but it’s happy, sexy and smiling. So it’s not a problem for me. It’s sexy because her conscious smile communicates to us clear consent. Not rape or anything against her will.

  4. While I can understand the rape concerns, that retort from a Twitter follower says to me that 1) they are likely to be extremely politically correct (which is a major peeve of mine), and 2) totally clueless and reading something into that photo that isn’t even there. I’ve seen that photo here many times and NOT ONCE did I ever see it as rape. Maybe yeah, guys wanting to lift her clothing off for a better look (and her smile being very encouraging in that respect ;) ), but why should I read “rape” into that photo? Seems someone is being hyper-sensitive.

    Maybe you’ve seen it before, but there is an album cover from the late 70s by a group called Love and Kisses. (It’s hard to miss if you Google it.) It’s very similar in concept, and to my adolescent eyes, that little bit of peek-a-boo was more than a tease. ;) And I never considered that a depiction of rape either.

    As for rape, even at my *ahem* advanced aged, I had learned decades ago that “rape” was any forcible non-consensual act, not just “penetration” like the FBI describes it. Kind of a broad definition, but it was geared more towards girls and women who felt they’d had something done to them against their will, and to encourage them to report it to the authorities. And I fully agree REAL rape is a bad thing. I have two daughters to worry about, one going off to college in a few years. And the climate at many universities towards rape victims is alarming (look at UVA).

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.


WARNING: Explicit Content
The content you are about to view is intended for adults. If you are not of legal age or are easily offended by the human body, sexual anatomy, or words like "penis" or "vagina", it's suggested that you click the exit button. You have been warned. Your kids have been warned.
Facebook IconTwitter IconFollow me on TumblrFollow me on Tumblr
nmd runnner nmd runnner black nmd runnner white nmd runnner grey nmd runnner gs ultra boost ultra boost black ultra boost white ultra boost grey ultra boost gs ultra boost uncaged ultra boost uncaged black ultra boost uncaged white ultra boost uncaged grey ultra boost uncaged gs yeezy boost 350 yeezy boost 350 black yeezy boost 350 white yeezy boost 350 grey yeezy boost 350 gs yeezy boost 350 v2 yeezy boost 350 v2 black yeezy boost 350 v2 white yeezy boost 350 v2 grey yeezy boost 350 v2 gs yeezy boost 750 yeezy boost 750 black yeezy boost 750 white yeezy boost 750 grey yeezy boost 750 gs